Learn: risk and leverage
What is a stablecoin, and how can it lose its peg?
A stablecoin is a token designed to trade at a fixed value, usually one US dollar. It holds that value only through what stands behind it: cash and short-term bills that can be redeemed, crypto locked above the value, or an algorithm and a sister token. Every design can lose its peg, and some have lost it for good.
How it works
A stablecoin is a promise, not a bank deposit. The promise is that one coin is worth one unit of something, almost always a dollar. Whether the promise holds depends on a single question: what can a holder actually get for the coin, and how quickly? The marketing, the size of the supply and the number of venues that list it say nothing about that.
There are three broad designs. A fiat-backed coin is issued against reserves held off chain, such as cash, bank deposits and short-term government bills, and approved customers can redeem coins for dollars. A crypto-collateralised coin is minted against crypto locked in a smart contract, worth more than the coins issued, and the position is liquidated if the collateral falls too far. An algorithmic coin has little or no outside backing and relies on code that mints and burns a sister token to pull the price back to one.
A depeg is the market telling you it doubts the promise. What a price of 0.97 means depends on the design. For a fiat-backed coin it is a question about the reserves and the redemption door. For a crypto-collateralised coin it is a question about the collateral and its liquidations. For an algorithmic coin it can be the start of a spiral, because the only thing defending the peg is a token whose value depends on confidence in the peg.
The exact rule the games grade by
The rule the games use: classify a design only from the facts that decide it (who holds what reserves, whether redemption is open, whether collateral is locked above the value, whether a sister token is minted to defend the peg). Decoy facts such as an audit, a big supply, a yield or "dollar" in the name never decide it. A depeg is read by design: fiat-backed = redemption (the arbitrage is 1 / price - 1, which is 3.09% at 0.97, if redemption is open to you and the reserves exist); crypto-collateralised = the collateral; algorithmic = a possible spiral. In the bank run game, each day holders redeem a share of what is outstanding, cash pays first, other reserves sell at par only after their horizon or at a haircut before it, and the issuer fails on the first day it cannot pay in full.
Step by step
- Find what backs the coin: reserves off chain, collateral on chain, or only an algorithm and a sister token.
- Ask who can redeem, for what, and how fast. Open redemption for the public is different from redemption for approved institutions only.
- Check whether the reserves are liquid: cash and very short bills can pay on day one; longer bonds and loans can only be sold at a loss in a hurry.
- Ignore the decoys: an audit badge, a large supply, a yield on the coin, or a name with "dollar" in it.
- If it trades below 1.00, read the depeg by design: redemption, collateral, or spiral.
Backed is not the same as liquid
A stablecoin with reserves above 100% can still fail a run. If many holders want out at once, the issuer must pay in cash today, and reserves that are sound but slow, such as longer bonds, can only be sold quickly at a discount. Each fire sale shrinks the reserves relative to what is still outstanding, which can frighten the next wave of holders. That feedback loop is what Stablecoin Run simulates day by day.
Worked example
Say a fiat-backed stablecoin trades at 0.97 on the open market. If you could buy it there and redeem it with the issuer for exactly 1.00, you would make 1 / 0.97 - 1 = 3.09% before fees. That gap is what normally pulls the price back: traders with access to redemption buy the cheap coins and hand them in.
Now look at the conditions. The arbitrage works only if redemption is open to the person holding the coin (often it is limited to approved customers with large minimums), if the issuer actually honours it in time, and if the reserves exist and are worth what they claim. A 0.97 price that stays there is the market saying at least one of those conditions is in doubt.
The same 0.97 means something else for the other designs. For a crypto-collateralised coin, the question is whether the locked collateral still covers the coins after its liquidations; a sharp crypto fall can test that. For an algorithmic coin, the defence is to mint more of a sister token to absorb coins below the peg, which can push the sister token down and weaken the defence further.
Takeaway: A depeg to 0.97 is a question, not a bargain: for a fiat-backed coin the 3.09% gap only exists for someone who can really redeem, against reserves that really exist.
Common mistakes
- Treating a stablecoin like a bank deposit. Stablecoins usually carry no deposit insurance, and holders may have no direct claim on the reserves. A promise of one dollar is only as good as the issuer and the assets behind it.
- Trusting the name or the size. A large supply, many listings or "dollar" in the name tell you nothing about the backing. Decide the design from the reserve and redemption facts only.
- Buying a depeg as a sure profit. A coin at 0.97 can go back to 1.00, stay there, or fall further. The redemption arbitrage is only real if you can redeem; otherwise you are betting on someone else doing it.
- Chasing yield on a stablecoin without asking where it comes from. A high yield paid on a "stable" coin has to come from somewhere: lending, risky reserves or new money. See APY vs APR and ask the source every time.
What this does not tell you, and what can go wrong
Knowing the design tells you how a stablecoin is supposed to work, not whether its issuer is honest, solvent or able to pay this week. Reserve reports are usually snapshots or attestations, not full audits, and a snapshot cannot show what happened the day after. See proof of reserves for the limits of these reports.
History shows every design can break. In May 2022 the algorithmic stablecoin TerraUSD (UST) lost its peg and collapsed within days, taking its sister token LUNA down with it and wiping out tens of billions of dollars of value. In March 2023 a large fiat-backed stablecoin briefly traded well below one dollar after its issuer disclosed that part of its reserves were held at Silicon Valley Bank, which had just failed; it recovered once the deposits were made safe. A coin that recovered once is not guaranteed to recover again.
The models in the games are simplified for training: real runs also depend on legal rights, banking hours, regulators and news, which no facts sheet captures.
Questions people ask
Are stablecoins safe?
Safer than a volatile coin against price swings on a normal day, but not safe in the way an insured bank deposit is. Each one depends on its issuer, its reserves or collateral, and its redemption terms. Stablecoins have lost their peg before, some briefly and some permanently. Read what backs a coin before you hold it, and do not keep more there than you could afford to lose.
What does it mean when a stablecoin depegs?
It trades away from its target value, usually below one dollar. A small, brief gap can come from thin liquidity. A larger or lasting gap means the market doubts the backing, the redemption process or the mechanism. What it means in practice depends on the design: redemption for fiat-backed coins, collateral for crypto-collateralised ones, and a possible spiral for algorithmic ones.
What is the difference between fiat-backed and algorithmic stablecoins?
A fiat-backed coin is issued against reserves held off chain, such as cash and short-term government bills, and can be redeemed for dollars by eligible holders. An algorithmic coin has little or no outside backing and relies on code that mints and burns a sister token to defend the peg. When confidence breaks, the algorithmic design has nothing outside itself to fall back on.
Can I always redeem a stablecoin for one dollar?
Often not directly. Many issuers only redeem for approved customers, with minimum amounts, fees and processing times. Most holders can only sell on the market, at whatever price buyers offer. That is why the redemption arbitrage of 1 / price - 1 helps the peg only if enough people who can redeem are willing and able to do it.
Practise it
Reading about a rule is not the same as applying it. These games generate a fresh simulation each round, ask you to make the call first, and grade you against the same rule.
Stablecoin Check
Classify a stablecoin from its facts sheet, or read what a depeg below 1.00 means for its design.
Stablecoin Run
Run a stablecoin treasury through a bank run: pay redemptions, sell the right reserves first, and see whether it holds.